What we should learn from Garner and Ferguson cases

What we should learn from Garner and Ferguson cases

This is not the first time we have struggled with this anguish and it will not be the last. But there may be a new prospect for hope this time.

We can begin by enhancing the perception of fairness of the official response when police use deadly force.

Much of the anger being expressed across the country comes from the fact that after these deaths, the criminal justice system suddenly seems helpless when invoked in their defense.

Importantly, the problem is not as many have suggested that the prosecutors in Ferguson and Staten Island presented exculpatory evidence to the respective grand juries. The grand jurors in Ferguson and Staten Island were doing something different. They were taking the place of the prosecutor, do whether to bring criminal charges. While we generally trust prosecutors to make charging decisions, there is good reason not to trust them when the suspect is a police officer. The grand jury should make the charging decision in these cases, both in terms of actual fairness and public perception. If the grand jury is acting as the prosecutor, however, it must see all the evidence.

One of the worst outcomes of recent events would be if prosecutors and grand jurors internalize the notion that the public wants cases to advance to trial notwithstanding substantial doubts about guilt. There are already thousands of defendants across the country jailed pending trial, trying to choose between pleading guilty to a shaky charge or risking a much higher sentence at trial.

Police deadly force cases should go to grand juries, and the grand jurors should see all the relevant evidence, but the presentation should be guided not by a prosecutor, but by a "special counsel," an attorney completely independent of the local police and prosecuting authority.

There is a model for this approach.

 

  • Three cowards beat an autistic man in Ottawa bus terminal

    Three cowards beat an autistic man in Ottawa bus terminal

    The Peel police are currently on the lookout for three men who ganged up on an autistic man at the Ottawa bus terminal on March 13, 2018. Surveillance video captured and subsequently released by the Peel police clearly showed the trio of men punching and kicking the helpless victim before walking…

  • How did Eddie Tipton scam the Colorado Lottery?

    How did Eddie Tipton scam the Colorado Lottery?

    Eddie Tipton, former security director of the Association of US Multi-State Lottery, was in charge of installing software for the lottery machines. However, the man hacked the system to give himself some advantage by finding predictable jackpots. Not only did this give him the chance to predict all…

  • Bekre Abdela accused of acid attack in Maryland

    Bekre Abdela accused of acid attack in Maryland

    An Ethiopian immigrant, Bekre Abdela was charged with the attempted murder of a young Maryland woman. Bekre’s weapon of choice was acid. This left his roommate’s face scarred for life. The suspect is said to have used sulphuric acid on the woman’s face. As a result, the woman…

What happened to Fauna Jackson (16) while missing in Grand Teton National Park?

What happened to Fauna Jackson (16) while missing in Grand Teton National Park?

Fauna Jackson was last seen on Thursday, August 4th and a large search was started. The 16-year-old from Ohio was volunteering in Wyoming´s Grand Teton National Park. After 24 hours, a group of 60 people were combing the national park in search of Ms. Jackson. By Saturday, more than 100 people…

read more
Hostage Robert Hall beheaded and how he became a hostage

Hostage Robert Hall beheaded and how he became a hostage

When you think about luxury resorts, you don’t ever imagine that something evil could happen to you while you are on vacation. Unfortunately, this was the case of Robert Hall, a Canadian citizen who went on vacation to the Philippines and stayed at a seaside resort. Robert was kidnapped with…

read more
Canadian funded hospital destroyed in Syria

Canadian funded hospital destroyed in Syria

A Canadian-funded hospital in Syria has been destroyed during an air strike that was, according to an aid agency, deliberate and has forced other hospitals to close. This hospital was in Aleppo, a city divided by Syrian President Bashar Assad government forces and Syrian rebels. The center is one…

read more
N. Korean submarine considered sunk

N. Korean submarine considered sunk

A North Korean submarine disappeared and is presumed to have sunk. The submarine was reportedly operating and patrolling the North Korean coast for several days before it went missing. An unknown news source from the U.S government stated that the submarine sunk and is not missing. North Korea has…

read more
Boko Haram attack village in Nigeria, Feb. 1, 2016

Boko Haram attack village in Nigeria, Feb. 1, 2016

"We had just finished evening prayers when the gunmen came to our village and indiscriminately opened fire and set fire to homes," were the words of resident Kulo Sheriff. The extremist group, Boko Haram viciously attacked Dalori village in the north of the country with gunfire and…

read more
San Bernadino Shooting is the New Phase of Terrorism

San Bernadino Shooting is the New Phase of Terrorism

On December 6th, 2015, President Obama vowed to find anyone who plotted militant attacks on the U.S.A. He said this to reassure Americans after the California deadly rampage shooting, which has provoked questions regarding security of the United States against extremism. He did his best to respond…

read more